Motor Insurance Bureau Caselaw Database
Malcolm Johnson, the principal of this firm began his legal career specialising in road traffic accidents claims. He went on to write a number of articles in this field, before being asked by Central Law Training to lecture on the subject of claims against the Motor Insurers’ Bureau. He now gives lectures to law firms across England and Wales on this subject. He has also contributed to “Claims against the Motor Insurers’ Bureau” published by the Law Society.
MIB claims do cause difficulty for practitioners. The MIB is not like a normal insurance company and the provisions of the 1999 and 2003 Agreements can cause problems. Over the years, the courts have dealt with claims against the MIB and made judgments that have, to some extent, clarified the law in this area. The MIB Caselaw Database aims to provide busy practitioners with a series of signposts to the relevant cases and an overview of what the court is saying in each case.
If you wish to know more about training courses provided by Central Law Training on Claims against the MIB, click here or click the CLT logo
Some of the cases in this Caselaw Library do not involve the Motor Insurers’ Bureau, but they relate instead to issues of road traffic and motor insurance. These cases have been included because they relate to issues that impact on cases involving the Bureau, such as “knowledge of no insurance.“
There is no charge for using the constantly updated database. We invite comments and suggestions from users, who should use the contact box to the right of this paragraph.
1865
1935
1936
1938
1940
1941
1946
1948
1950
- Weldrick v Essex and Suffolk Equitable Insurance Society Ltd [1949-50]
- Corfield v Groves and Another [1950]
1951
1952
1953
- Ormrod v Crosville Motor Services Ltd 1953
- Ceylon Motor Insurance Association v Thambugala 1953
- Baker v Market Harborough Industrial Cooperative Society [1953]
1958
1960
1961
1963
1964
- Hardy v Motor Insurers’ Bureau [1964]
- R v Beaumont [1964]
- Adams v Andrews 1964
- Fire, Auto and Marine Insurance Co Ltd v Greene [1964]
1965
1966
1967
1968
1969
1970
1971
1973
1974
1976
- R v Mohan (John Patrick) [1976]
- R v Miele [1976]
- R v Lucas [1976]
- R v Lidster [1976]
- Cox v White [1976]
1978
1979
1980
1981
1983
1984
1985
- Pera Shipping Corp v Petroship SA;[1985]
- Nancollas v Insurance Officer; Ball v Insurance Officer [1985]
- Cooper v Motor Insurers Bureau 1985
- Meah v McCreamer [1985]
1986
- Alpine Bulk Transport Co Inc v Saudi Eagle Shipping Co Inc (the “Saudi Eagle”) 1986
- Thomas v Hooper; Thomas v Cooper [1986]
1987
1988
1989
- Smith v Stages [1989]
- Harrington and Another v Link Motor Policies at Lloyd’s;Sub Nom. Harrington v Pinkey [1989]
1990
- Smith v Ainger [1990]
- Marleasing SA v LA Comercial Internacional de Alimentacion SA (CASE C-106/89) 1990
- Limbrick v French and Farley [1990]
- Pitts v Hunt [1991]
1992
- R v Cambridge Magistrates Court Ex P. WONG [1992]
- International Distillers & Vintners Limited (t/a Percy Fox & Company) v JF Hillebrand (UK) Limited and Others [1999]
1994
1995
- Mather v Adesuyi; Mather v Motor Insurers Bureau [1995]
- Heer v Tutton and Another [1995]
- Blanksby v Turner 1995
- Granada UK Rental and Retail v SPN Fareway and Motor Insurers Bureau [1995]
- Mastin v Blanchard and Motor Insurers Bureau [1995]
- Mills v Toner and the Motor Insurers Bureau [1995]
- Wagner Miret v Fondo de Garantia Salarial (Case C-334/92) [1993]
- Stinton v Stinton; Sub Nom. Stinton v Motor Insurers Bureau [1995]
1996
- R v Austin (Nicholas) [1996]
- Page v Smith [1996]
- Hatton v Hall and Another [1996]
- Criminal Proceedings against Ruiz Bernáldez (Case C-129/94) 1996
- Brasserie du Pecheur SA v Germany 1996
1997
- Silverton v Goodall [1997]
- O’Neill v O’Brien; O’Neill v Motor Insurers Bureau [1997]
- Oldham v Sharples [1997]
- McDermott v DPP [1997]
- Baker v Francis 1997
- Burrows v Vauxhall Motors Ltd 1997
1998
- Clarke v Kato; Sub Nom. Clarke v General Accident Fire and Life Assurance Corp PLC; Cutter v Eagle Star Insurance Co Ltd [1998]
- Widdowson v Newgate Meat Corp [1998]
- Ahmed v DPP 1998
1999
- Sharp v Pereira; Sub Nom. Sharp v Pereir; Sharp v Motor Insurers’ Bureau [1999]
- Evans v Motor Insurers Bureau; Mighell v Reading; White v White [1999]
- Mighell v Reading [1999]
- O’mahony v Joliffe And The Motor Insurers Bureau [1999]
- DPP v Jowle [1999]
- Desouza v Waterloo [1999]
2000
- Dodson v Peter H Dodson Insurance Services (A Firm) [2001]
- Norman v Aziz; Norman v Ali [2000]
- Sadiku v DPP [2000]
- R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board EX P. M (A Minor); R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board EX. P. Keane [2000]
- Greatorex v Greatorex [2000]
- Cawthorn v Director of Public Prosecutions 2000
- Henry Boot Construction (UK) Ltd v Malmaison Hotel (Manchester) Ltd [2000]
2001
- Wake v Page and Another [2001]
- Starmark Enterprises Ltd v CPL Distribution Ltd [2001]
- Charlton v. Fisher And Another [2001]
- White v White And Another [2001]
- Evans v The Secretary Of State For The Environment, Transport And The Regions And The Motor Insurers Bureau [2001] Court of Appeal
- Evans v The Secretary Of State For The Environment, Transport And The Regions And The Motor Insurers Bureau [2001]
- Inman v Kenny [2001]
- Hatton v Cooper [2001]
- Director of Public Prosecutions v Saddington [2001]
- Caple v Sewell and Others 2001
- Hatton v Cooper [2001]
2002
- Winter v DPP [2002]
- Evans v The Secretary Of State For The Environment, Transport And The Regions And The Motor Insurers Bureau – Opinion Of Advocate General
- Planton v Director of Public Prosecutions [2002]
2003
- Akers v Motor Insurers Bureau [2003]
- Conti v Hugh James (A Firm) (2003)
- Drake Insurance Plc v Provident Insurance Plc [2003]
- Evans v The Secretary Of State For The Environment, Transport And The Regions And The Motor Insurers Bureau – Case c-63/01 [2003]
- Nawaz And Hussain v Crowe Insurance Group [2003]
2004
- Young v Highway Insurance Agency Ltd [2004]
- Brewer v Director Of Public Prosecutions [2005]
- Hazel (For Lloyd’s Syndicate 260, t/a kgm Motor Policies At Lloyd’s v Whitlam [2004]
- Keeley v Pashen And Another [2004]
- Lloyd Wolper v Moore And Another [2004]
- Mohindra v Director Of Public Prosecutions; Browne versus Chief Constable Of The Greater Manchester Police [2004]
- Pickett v Motor Insurers Bureau [2004]
- R v Marchant, R v Muntz [2004]
- Slater v Buckinghamshire County Council, Stigwood and Norwich Union PLC [2004]
2005
2006
- Candolin v Vahinkovakuutusosakeyhtio Pohjola [2006]
- Collier v Williams, Marshall And Another v Maggs, Leeson v Marsden And Another, Glass v Surrendran [2006]
- Evans v Secretary Of State For The Environment Transport And The Regions And Another [2006]
- Horton versus Sadler And Another [2006]
- Miller v Hales [2007]
- Palmer v Estate Of Palmer And Others [2006]
- Phillips (Administratrix Of The Estate Of Neville Phillips Decesased) v Rafiq (1) And The MIB 2006
- Richardson v Watson And Another [2006]
2007
- Byrne (A Minor) v The Motor Insurers Bureau And The Secretary Of State For Transport [2007]
- Farrell v The Minister For The Environment (Ireland) And The Motor Insurers Bureau Of Ireland [2007]
- Moore v Secretary Of State For Transport (1) Motor Insurers’ Bureau (2) [2007]
- Phillips (As Representative Of The Estate Of Neville Phillips Deceased) And Rafiq (1) And The MIB (2) [2007]
2008
- Williams v Johnstone [2008]
- Turner v Green and Another [2008]
- Spencer v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions – Moore v Secretary of State for Transport and Motor Insurers Bureau [2008]
- Palmer v Estate of Palmer and Others [2008]
- McCall v Poulton, MIB and Another [2008]
- Cain v Francis; McKay and Hamlani v Direct Line Insurance PLC 2008
- Byrne (a minor) v The Motor Insurers Bureau and the Secretary of State for Transport 2008
2009
- Wilkinson (By his Father and Litigation Friend Stephen Wilkinson) v Fitzgerald and Churchill Insurance Company Limited [2009]
- Sloan v Motor Insurers’ Bureau [2009]
- R (On the Application of Tait) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel [2009]
- Shapoor v Promo Designs Unreported [2009]
- Barr and Others v Biffa Waste Services Ltd [2009]
- Adding in the MIB as Defendant
- Ambiguity of Documents
- Application for "Divided Proof"
- Arbitration Acts
- Breach of insurance policy
- Claimant's Road Safety Competence
- Clause 13 of the MIB Uninsured Drivers Agreement 1999
- Contributory Negligence
- Criminal injuries compensation authority
- Definition of Public Place
- Dependants of deceased making claim against MIB
- Disclosure of ATE Insurance Policy
- Distinction between 'untraced' and 'uninsured'
- Effect of EU Law
- Effect of Suicide on Life Insurance
- Effective Commencement of Insurance Policy
- Entitlement to Costs
- Evidential Issues and Negligence
- Failing to provide information
- failure to comply with MIB Agreement
- Failure to notify of issue of proceedings
- Failure to notify of issue of proceedings
- Insurance against Third Party Risks
- Insurer's right of recovery under Section 151 of the Road Traffice Act 1988
- Interim Payment
- Knowledge of no insurance
- Late Service of Defence
- Liability of Animal Owners
- Liability of Insurers
- Liability of Owner of Vehicle
- Liability of Passengers in Control
- Liability under Road Traffic Act 1988
- Liability under the Road Traffic Act 1972
- Limitation
- Meaning of Driving
- Meaning of road
- Meaning of Vehicle
- MIB'S right of recovery against another party
- Oil spill on road
- Operation of MIB Untraced Drivers Agreement
- Policy Limitations Affecting Duty of Care
- Re-issue of proceedings against MIB after expiry of limitation
- Rights of Subrogation
- Service of proceedings
- Setting Aside Judgement
- Special Reasons for Disqualification
- Use of vehicle
- Use of Vehicle in the Course of Employment
- Validity of Summons
- Vehicle used in unauthorised activities or crime
- Vicarious liability
- Voluntary Intoxication
Adding in the MIB as Defendant
- Fire, Auto and Marine Insurance Co Ltd v Greene [1964]
- Gurtner v Circuit [1968]
- White v London Transport Executive [1971]
- Mills v Toner and the Motor Insurers Bureau [1995]
- Mastin v Blanchard and Motor Insurers Bureau [1995]
- Granada UK Rental and Retail v SPN Fareway and Motor Insurers Bureau [1995]
- Sharp v Pereira; Sub Nom. Sharp v Pereir; Sharp v Motor Insurers’ Bureau [1999]
- Palmer v Estate Of Palmer And Others [2006]
Ambiguity of Documents
Application for "Divided Proof"
Arbitration Acts
Breach of insurance policy
- Monk v Warbey & Others [1935]
- Starkey v Hall [1936]
- McGoona v Motor Insurers Bureau [1969]
- Dodson v Peter H Dodson Insurance Services (A Firm) [2001]
- Drake Insurance Plc v Provident Insurance Plc [2003]
- Lloyd Wolper v Moore And Another [2004]
- Hazel (For Lloyd’s Syndicate 260, t/a kgm Motor Policies At Lloyd’s v Whitlam [2004]
Claimant's Road Safety Competence
Clause 13 of the MIB Uninsured Drivers Agreement 1999
Contributory Negligence
- Baker v Market Harborough Industrial Cooperative Society [1953]
- Rouse v Squires and Others [1973]
- Howard v Bemrose [1973]
- Meah v McCreamer [1985]
- Pitts v Hunt [1991]
- Widdowson v Newgate Meat Corp [1998]
- Hatton v Cooper [2001]
- Hatton v Cooper [2001]
Criminal injuries compensation authority
Definition of Public Place
Effect of EU Law
- Marleasing SA v LA Comercial Internacional de Alimentacion SA (CASE C-106/89) 1990
- Wagner Miret v Fondo de Garantia Salarial (Case C-334/92) [1993]
- Criminal Proceedings against Ruiz Bernáldez (Case C-129/94) 1996
- Brasserie du Pecheur SA v Germany 1996
- Silverton v Goodall [1997]
Effect of Suicide on Life Insurance
Effective Commencement of Insurance Policy
Entitlement to Costs
Evidential Issues and Negligence
- Scott v London Dock Co [1865]
- Woods v Duncan [1946]
- Jones v Metcalfe [1967]
- Elizabeth v Motor Insurers Bureau [1981]
- Ahmed v DPP 1998
- Slater v Buckinghamshire County Council, Stigwood and Norwich Union PLC [2004]
- Turner v Green and Another [2008]
Failing to provide information
failure to comply with MIB Agreement
- Limbrick v French and Farley [1990]
- R v Austin (Nicholas) [1996]
- Silverton v Goodall [1997]
- Sharp v Pereira; Sub Nom. Sharp v Pereir; Sharp v Motor Insurers’ Bureau [1999]
Failure to notify of issue of proceedings
- Herbert v Railway Passengers Assurance Co [1938]
- Weldrick v Essex and Suffolk Equitable Insurance Society Ltd [1949-50]
- Ceylon Motor Insurance Association v Thambugala 1953
- Harrington and Another v Link Motor Policies at Lloyd’s;Sub Nom. Harrington v Pinkey [1989]
- Silverton v Goodall [1997]
- Desouza v Waterloo [1999]
- Wake v Page and Another [2001]
Failure to notify of issue of proceedings
Insurance against Third Party Risks
- Monk v Warbey & Others [1935]
- Corfield v Groves and Another [1950]
- Cooper v Motor Insurers Bureau 1985
Insurer's right of recovery under Section 151 of the Road Traffice Act 1988
- Adams v Andrews 1964
- Wake v Page and Another [2001]
- Young v Highway Insurance Agency Ltd [2004]
- Wilkinson (By his Father and Litigation Friend Stephen Wilkinson) v Fitzgerald and Churchill Insurance Company Limited [2009]
Interim Payment
Knowledge of no insurance
Late Service of Defence
Liability of Animal Owners
Liability of Insurers
- Cleland v London General Insurance Co Ltd [1935]
- Croxford v Universal Insurance Co Ltd [1936]
- Herbert v Railway Passengers Assurance Co [1938]
- Caple v Sewell and Others 2001
Liability of Owner of Vehicle
- Monk v Warbey & Others [1935]
- Hewitt v Bonvin [1940]
- Ormrod v Crosville Motor Services Ltd 1953
- Martin v Dean and Another [1971]
- Klein v Caluori [1971]
Liability of Passengers in Control
Liability under Road Traffic Act 1988
Liability under the Road Traffic Act 1972
Limitation
- Miller v National Coal Board [1960]
- Liff v Peasley and Another [1980]
- International Distillers & Vintners Limited (t/a Percy Fox & Company) v JF Hillebrand (UK) Limited and Others [1999]
- Starmark Enterprises Ltd v CPL Distribution Ltd [2001]
- Spencer v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions – Moore v Secretary of State for Transport and Motor Insurers Bureau [2008]
- Cain v Francis; McKay and Hamlani v Direct Line Insurance PLC 2008
- Byrne (a minor) v The Motor Insurers Bureau and the Secretary of State for Transport 2008
- Williams v Johnstone [2008]
Meaning of Driving
Meaning of road
- Bugge v Taylor 1941
- Purves v Muir [1948]
- Thomas v Dando [1951]
- Griffin v Squires [1958]
- R v Beaumont [1964]
- Randall v Motor Insurers Bureau [1969]
- Cox v White [1976]
- Adams v Commissioner of Police 1980
- Oxford v Austin [1981]
- Clarke v Kato; Sub Nom. Clarke v General Accident Fire and Life Assurance Corp PLC; Cutter v Eagle Star Insurance Co Ltd [1998]
- Sadiku v DPP [2000]
Meaning of Vehicle
- Daley and Others v Hargreaves 1961
- Smart v Allen; Sub Nom. Smart v Allan [1963]
- Burns v Currell 1963
- O’Brien v Anderton [1979]
- Reader v Bunyard [1987]
- Chief Constable of Avon and Somerset v Fleming 1987
- O’Neill v O’Brien; O’Neill v Motor Insurers Bureau [1997]
- Director of Public Prosecutions v Saddington [2001]
- Winter v DPP [2002]
MIB'S right of recovery against another party
Operation of MIB Untraced Drivers Agreement
Policy Limitations Affecting Duty of Care
Rights of Subrogation
Service of proceedings
- Mather v Adesuyi; Mather v Motor Insurers Bureau [1995]
- Silverton v Goodall [1997]
- Starmark Enterprises Ltd v CPL Distribution Ltd [2001]
Setting Aside Judgement
Special Reasons for Disqualification
Use of vehicle
- Elliott v Grey [1960]
- Brown v Roberts 1965
- Seddon v Binions [1978]
- Leathley v Tatton [1980]
- B (a Minor) v Knight 1981
- Thomas v Hooper; Thomas v Cooper [1986]
- Stinton v Stinton; Sub Nom. Stinton v Motor Insurers Bureau [1995]
- Hatton v Hall and Another [1996]
Use of Vehicle in the Course of Employment
- R v Wibberley (Glen Merrie) [1966]
- Rogers v Night Riders [1983]
- Nancollas v Insurance Officer; Ball v Insurance Officer [1985]
- Smith v Stages [1989]
Validity of Summons
Vehicle used in unauthorised activities or crime
- Mowe v Perraton [1952]
- Hardy v Motor Insurers’ Bureau [1964]
- R v Wibberley (Glen Merrie) [1966]
- R v Phipps 1970 and R. V Mcgill [1970]
- McKnight v Davies [1974]
- R v Mohan (John Patrick) [1976]
- R v Miele [1976]
- R v Lucas [1976]
- R v Lidster [1976]
- Gardner v Moore [1984]
- Pitts v Hunt [1991]
- R v Austin (Nicholas) [1996]
- R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board EX P. M (A Minor); R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board EX. P. Keane [2000]
- Charlton v. Fisher And Another [2001]
- Young v Highway Insurance Agency Ltd [2004]
- Keeley v Pashen And Another [2004]
- Sloan v Motor Insurers’ Bureau [2009]
Voluntary Intoxication
County Court
- Vose v Barr [1966]
- S (A Child) v Goldstraw 2005
- Granada UK Rental and Retail v SPN Fareway and Motor Insurers Bureau [1995]
- Mastin v Blanchard and Motor Insurers Bureau [1995]
- Mills v Toner and the Motor Insurers Bureau [1995]
Court of Appeal
- Monk v Warbey & Others [1935]
- Sharp v Pereira; Sub Nom. Sharp v Pereir; Sharp v Motor Insurers’ Bureau [1999]
- White v Weston [1968]
- Willowgreen v Smithers [1994]
- Winter v DPP [2002]
- Wake v Page and Another [2001]
- Stinton v Stinton; Sub Nom. Stinton v Motor Insurers Bureau [1995]
- Spencer v Secretary of State for Work and Pensions – Moore v Secretary of State for Transport and Motor Insurers Bureau [2008]
- Akers v Motor Insurers Bureau [2003]
- Bretton v Hancock [2005]
- Charlton v. Fisher And Another [2001]
- Collier v Williams, Marshall And Another v Maggs, Leeson v Marsden And Another, Glass v Surrendran [2006]
- Dodson v Peter H Dodson Insurance Services (A Firm) [2001]
- Drake Insurance Plc v Provident Insurance Plc [2003]
- Evans v The Secretary Of State For The Environment, Transport And The Regions And The Motor Insurers Bureau [2001] Court of Appeal
- Evans v The Secretary Of State For The Environment, Transport And The Regions And The Motor Insurers Bureau [2001]
- Hazel (For Lloyd’s Syndicate 260, t/a kgm Motor Policies At Lloyd’s v Whitlam [2004]
- Keeley v Pashen And Another [2004]
- Lloyd Wolper v Moore And Another [2004]
- Mighell v Reading [1999]
- Nawaz And Hussain v Crowe Insurance Group [2003]
- O’mahony v Joliffe And The Motor Insurers Bureau [1999]
- Phillips (As Representative Of The Estate Of Neville Phillips Deceased) And Rafiq (1) And The MIB (2) [2007]
- Pickett v Motor Insurers Bureau [2004]
- Richardson v Watson And Another [2006]
- Smith v Ainger [1990]
- Silverton v Goodall [1997]
- Seddon v Binions [1978]
- Scott v London Dock Co [1865]
- Sadiku v DPP [2000]
- Rogers v Night Riders [1983]
- R v Phipps 1970 and R. V Mcgill [1970]
- R v Miele [1976]
- R v Lucas [1976]
- R v Lidster [1976]
- R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board EX P. M (A Minor); R v Criminal Injuries Compensation Board EX. P. Keane [2000]
- R v Beaumont [1964]
- R v Austin (Nicholas) [1996]
- R v Allen [1988]
- Persson v London Country Buses [1974]
- Palmer v Estate of Palmer and Others [2008]
- O’Neill v O’Brien; O’Neill v Motor Insurers Bureau [1997]
- Ormrod v Crosville Motor Services Ltd 1953
- Oldham v Sharples [1997]
- Nancollas v Insurance Officer; Ball v Insurance Officer [1985]
- McCall v Poulton, MIB and Another [2008]
- Mather v Adesuyi; Mather v Motor Insurers Bureau [1995]
- Liff v Peasley and Another [1980]
- Leathley v Tatton [1980]
- Hewitt v Bonvin [1940]
- Heer v Tutton and Another [1995]
- Hatton v Cooper [2001]
- Gomberg v Smith [1963]
- Elizabeth v Motor Insurers Bureau [1981]
- Dunthorne v Bentley [1996]
- Director of Public Prosecutions v Saddington [2001]
- Desouza v Waterloo [1999]
- Cooper v Motor Insurers Bureau 1985
- Cleland v London General Insurance Co Ltd [1935]
- Cartwright v MacCormack 1963
- Carpenter v Ebblewhite 1938
- Caple v Sewell and Others 2001
- Cambridge v Motors Insurance Bureau; Sub Nom. Cambridge v Callaghan 1998
- Cain v Francis; McKay and Hamlani v Direct Line Insurance PLC 2008
- Blanksby v Turner 1995
- Baker v Francis 1997
- Slater v Buckinghamshire County Council, Stigwood and Norwich Union PLC [2004]
- Harrington and Another v Link Motor Policies at Lloyd’s;Sub Nom. Harrington v Pinkey [1989]
- R v Wibberley (Glen Merrie) [1966]
- R v Mohan (John Patrick) [1976]
- R v Marchant, R v Muntz [2004]
- Croxford v Universal Insurance Co Ltd [1936]
- Inman v Kenny [2001]
- Burrows v Vauxhall Motors Ltd 1997
- Byrne (a minor) v The Motor Insurers Bureau and the Secretary of State for Transport 2008
- Baker v Market Harborough Industrial Cooperative Society [1953]
- Howard v Bemrose [1973]
- Rouse v Squires and Others [1973]
- Pitts v Hunt [1991]
- Widdowson v Newgate Meat Corp [1998]
- Hatton v Cooper [2001]
- Alpine Bulk Transport Co Inc v Saudi Eagle Shipping Co Inc (the “Saudi Eagle”) 1986
- White v London Transport Executive [1971]
- Starmark Enterprises Ltd v CPL Distribution Ltd [2001]
- Pera Shipping Corp v Petroship SA;[1985]
- Henry Boot Construction (UK) Ltd v Malmaison Hotel (Manchester) Ltd [2000]
European Court of Justice
- Wagner Miret v Fondo de Garantia Salarial (Case C-334/92) [1993]
- Evans v The Secretary Of State For The Environment, Transport And The Regions And The Motor Insurers Bureau – Opinion Of Advocate General
- Farrell v The Minister For The Environment (Ireland) And The Motor Insurers Bureau Of Ireland [2007]
- Marleasing SA v LA Comercial Internacional de Alimentacion SA (CASE C-106/89) 1990
- Criminal Proceedings against Ruiz Bernáldez (Case C-129/94) 1996
- Brasserie du Pecheur SA v Germany 1996
High Court
- Fire, Auto and Marine Insurance Co Ltd v Greene [1964]
- Thomas v Hooper; Thomas v Cooper [1986]
- R (On the Application of Tait) v Criminal Injuries Compensation Appeals Panel [2009]
- Purves v Muir [1948]
- Limbrick v French and Farley [1990]
- Harrison v Hill [1932]
- Elliott v Grey [1960]
- Cox v White [1976]
- Barr and Others v Biffa Waste Services Ltd [2009]
High Court of Justice in Northern Ireland
House of Lords
- Woods v Duncan [1946]
- White v White And Another [2001]
- Gardner v Moore [1984]
- Horton versus Sadler And Another [2006]
- Smith v Stages [1989]
- Page v Smith [1996]
- Miller v National Coal Board [1960]
- Clarke v Kato; Sub Nom. Clarke v General Accident Fire and Life Assurance Corp PLC; Cutter v Eagle Star Insurance Co Ltd [1998]
- Beresford v Royal Insurance Co Ltd 1938
King's Bench Division
- Thomas v Dando [1951]
- Herbert v Railway Passengers Assurance Co [1938]
- Corfield v Groves and Another [1950]
- Bugge v Taylor 1941
- Starkey v Hall [1936]
- Weldrick v Essex and Suffolk Equitable Insurance Society Ltd [1949-50]
Magistrates Court
Privy Council
Queen's Bench
- Brewer v Director Of Public Prosecutions [2005]
- Byrne (A Minor) v The Motor Insurers Bureau And The Secretary Of State For Transport [2007]
- Evans v Secretary Of State For The Environment Transport And The Regions And Another [2006]
- Miller v Hales [2007]
- Mohindra v Director Of Public Prosecutions; Browne versus Chief Constable Of The Greater Manchester Police [2004]
- Moore v Secretary Of State For Transport (1) Motor Insurers’ Bureau (2) [2007]
- Palmer v Estate Of Palmer And Others [2006]
Queen's Bench Division
- McGoona v Motor Insurers Bureau [1969]
- Williams v Johnstone [2008]
- Young v Highway Insurance Agency Ltd [2004]
- Turner v Green and Another [2008]
- Smart v Allen; Sub Nom. Smart v Allan [1963]
- Scarsbrook v Mason [1961]
- Randall v Motor Insurers Bureau [1969]
- Pugsly v Hunter [1973]
- Planton v Director of Public Prosecutions [2002]
- O’Brien v Anderton [1979]
- Oxford v Austin [1981]
- Mowe v Perraton [1952]
- McKnight v Davies [1974]
- McDermott v DPP [1997]
- Martin v Dean and Another [1971]
- Klein v Caluori [1971]
- International Distillers & Vintners Limited (t/a Percy Fox & Company) v JF Hillebrand (UK) Limited and Others [1999]
- Griffin v Squires [1958]
- Greatorex v Greatorex [2000]
- DPP v Jowle [1999]
- Cawthorn v Director of Public Prosecutions 2000
- Burns v Currell 1963
- Jones v Metcalfe [1967]
- Chief Constable of Avon and Somerset v Fleming 1987
- Brown v Roberts 1965
- Meah v McCreamer [1985]
- Daley and Others v Hargreaves 1961
- Adams v Andrews 1964
- Adams v Commissioner of Police 1980
- Ahmed v DPP 1998
- B (a Minor) v Knight 1981
Romford County Court
Court of Appeal
